Paraphrasing tools in grad writing, where does the line fall

Summarize with AI

5

Working on my thesis and I’ve been running some of my more awkward sentences through QuillBot when I know what I mean but cant get the phrasing right, especially after a long day of writing when my brain just stops producing clean English. I always read the output and adjust it, never just paste and accept, but I keep second guessing if this counts as the kind of AI assistance my program’s integrity policy is warning me about, which is written pretty vaguely and mostly seems aimed at people using ChatGPT to write whole sections. Paraphrasing tools existed and were considered fine, if a little lazy, long before generative AI was really a thing, but now everything with the word AI attached to it seems to get lumped into the same suspicious category regardless of what it actually does. Where do people think the actual line is between acceptable writing assistance and something that needs to be disclosed or avoided entirely at the grad level?

4 replies

4 Replies

0

I think the honest test comes down to this: are the ideas and structure yours, with the tool just adjusting phrasing at the sentence level, versus the tool generating new content or arguments you didnt already have in your head. What you're describing, reading and adjusting every output, sounds like the former to me, which is a much lower risk category than people usually lump it into.

0

Ask your supervisor directly, honestly, rather than guessing at what a vague policy means. I asked mine the same question about Quillbot last year and she said explicitly that sentence level paraphrasing for clarity is fine and expected, she'd only have a problem if whole paragraphs of argument werent originally mine. Getting that in writing from her, even just an email, put my mind at ease.

0

@Jennifer Dhawan that's a good call, I think I've been avoiding asking because I was worried the question itself would look suspicious, but you're right that getting a direct answer beats guessing for the next two years of writing this thing.

0

For what its worth, most grad programs I know of draw the line exactly where @Scott Macdonald described, sentence level rewording of your own ideas is treated the same as always, getting a friend or editor to suggest better phrasing. The line moves once a tool is generating content you didnt already draft yourself, thats the actual dividing point most policies are trying to get at even when the wording is clumsy.